Should You Keep Fulfillment In-House or Outsource? The Answer Might Surprise You!

The Case for In-House Fulfillment

Greater Control Over Customer Experience

For brands focused on quality and customer satisfaction, in-house fulfillment offers the advantage of end-to-end oversight. You choose how items are packed, what packaging is used, and how fast they ship.

Easier Customization and Flexibility

If your products are fragile, heavily customized, or bundled differently depending on the sale, in-house teams can quickly adapt without complex standard operating procedures or change requests.

Cost Advantage at Low Volume

When your order volume is low or seasonal, it might be more cost-effective to handle it yourself, especially if you already have warehouse space or excess labor capacity.

However, this flips quickly. Once you cross a certain threshold (typically around 1,000–2,000 orders/month), the labor, space, and tech overhead can make outsourcing far more attractive.

The Case for Outsourcing Fulfillment

Scalability Without Operational Overhead

3PLs are built for scale. They can handle spikes in volume, expand into new regions, and absorb the logistics complexity that would bog down an internal team.

Access to Advanced Technology and Infrastructure

Most reputable 3PLs offer:

Robust warehouse management systems (WMS)
Real-time inventory tracking
Automated order routing
Discounted shipping rates via aggregated volume

Geographic Reach and Faster Delivery

Multi-node fulfillment from a 3PL network allows you to store inventory closer to customers. This reduces shipping times and costs—both critical in today’s Prime-conditioned world.

Example: An apparel brand saw a 23% drop in cart abandonment after moving to a bicoastal 3PL. Their 2-day shipping promise became reality, and customer satisfaction surged.

Lower Fixed Costs and Operational Risk

Managing your own warehouse means dealing with:

Lease agreements
Insurance and liability
OSHA compliance
Staffing, training, and turnover
Equipment maintenance

The Risks on Both Sides

In-House Pitfalls

Labor volatility: Warehouse turnover can be 30–40% annually. Constant hiring and training sap productivity.
Slow scalability: Opening a second facility or adding automation takes time and capital.
Opportunity cost: Every hour spent managing fulfillment is an hour not spent on product development or marketing.

Outsourcing Pitfalls

Loss of control: You depend on someone else to represent your brand.
Potential for misalignment: Some 3PLs prioritize volume over customization.
Hidden costs: Fees for storage, pick/pack, account management, kitting, etc., can add up fast.

Key Factors to Help You Decide

Order Volume and Growth Trajectory: If you're shipping under 500 orders/month, in-house may suffice. If you're scaling fast or forecasting rapid growth, you’ll want the infrastructure and flexibility of a 3PL.
Product Complexity: Are you shipping uniform items or fragile, regulated, or temperature-sensitive products? Some items demand more control and care than a generalist 3PL can offer.
Customer Expectations: Do your customers expect same-day shipping, custom packaging, or surprise elements? If yes, you’ll need a highly specialized 3PL—or keep it internal.
Geographic Strategy: Do you ship nationally or internationally? If you're fulfilling cross-border, partnering with a global 3PL can dramatically reduce customs headaches and shipping time.
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO): Compare apples to apples:
- In-house: labor, rent, utilities, insurance, packaging materials, software
- 3PL: pick/pack fees, storage, tech integrations, account fees
Model these out over 12–24 months to see where true cost efficiencies lie.

Hybrid Fulfillment: The Best of Both Worlds?

Many brands are exploring hybrid models:

In-house for high-touch, high-margin orders
3PL for standard DTC or B2B fulfillment
3PLs for overflow during peak seasons

Example: A beverage startup used in-house fulfillment for VIP influencer kits and outsourced the bulk of DTC volume. It gave them brand control and scalability.

Final Thoughts: There's No One-Size-Fits-All

Choosing between in-house fulfillment and a 3PL is a strategic decision that should be revisited as your business evolves. What worked at $1M in revenue might not work at $10M.

I always tell my clients: Audit your fulfillment every 6–12 months. Don’t be afraid to switch if your needs outgrow your current setup. And never choose based on cost alone—choose based on long-term operational fit.

Because in logistics, the wrong move isn't just inefficient—it can derail your growth, your brand, and your customer trust.

Choose wisely.

If you need assistance evaluating your fulfillment strategy or exploring 3PL options like Asia Cargo Container Line, Inc., feel free to reach out.

🌐 Website: www.asiacargo.com.ph

📧 Email: inquiries@asiacargo.com.ph

📞 Phone: +63 (2) 8527 2337 / +63 (2) 5328 3032

📍 Office Locations:

Head Office

No. 215, Unit 3107 World Trade Exchange Bldg, Juan Luna St., Binondo, Manila, Metro Manila, Philippines 1008

Port Office

ECJ Building, Rm. 101, Real St., Intramuros, Manila, Metro Manila, Philippines 1002